Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Rotation Advertisements



We hope you enjoy your visit to this forum.


If you are reading this then it means you are currently browsing the forum as a guest, we don’t limit any of the content posted from guests however if you join, you will have the ability to join the discussions! We are always happy to see new faces at this forum and we would like to hear your opinion, so why not register now? It doesn’t take long and you can get posting right away.


Click here to Register!

If you are having difficulties validating your account please email us at admin@dbzf.co.uk


If you're already a member please log in to your account:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Tenshinhan (23rd Tourney) vs. Entire U.S. Military
Topic Started: Aug 16 2014, 05:01 PM (6,800 Views)
POOHEAD189
Member Avatar


Tien at the 23rd vs. The Modern United States military. No Nukes, preferably, since this would probably be fought on American soil.
Tha gaol agam ort. <3
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Replies:
+ Pelador
Member Avatar
Crazy Awesome Legend

Tien is obviously stronger than Picollo at the 23rd. But does that mean he can copy that feat? The only ki blasts we see from him are a very weak kamehameha and the kikoho. Neither of which are anything close to that. Just because he's faster and hits harder, doesn't mean he's as masterful with his ki as King Picollo.


Posted Image

http://www.youtube.com/user/jonjits
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mihawk
Member Avatar


supersaqer
 
It is not inconsistency. I proved in an old topic here that 23rd TB Goku is moon level. That moves fine as we've seen Piccolo generating enough power to wipe and raze an island comparable to the size of a small continent even though Goku absorbed some of the blast.

As everything has already been answered by someone else, I'll reply to only this.

Your proof was wrong in someway since Goku claimed that Piccolo's island shaking shockwave was even greater than moon busting. And even if you did prove it wouldn't remove the inconsistency of Boo's charged beam doing the same damage.

Posted Image

Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ supersaqer
Member Avatar
Transcendent

Itachi
Aug 24 2014, 09:38 PM
supersaqer
 
It is not inconsistency. I proved in an old topic here that 23rd TB Goku is moon level. That moves fine as we've seen Piccolo generating enough power to wipe and raze an island comparable to the size of a small continent even though Goku absorbed some of the blast.

As everything has already been answered by someone else, I'll reply to only this.

Your proof was wrong in someway since Goku claimed that Piccolo's island shaking shockwave was even greater than moon busting. And even if you did prove it wouldn't remove the inconsistency of Boo's charged beam doing the same damage.
Although he did state that Piccolo's explosion was the greatest ki he felt, but doesn't have to include himself. He completely withstood the explosion, but wouldn't be capable of withstanding the Super Kamehameha in that crippled state. Goku probably meant it's the greatest ki he ever felt from somebody, and not including himself.

Base Goku, during the Frieza Saga, kicked Frieza through multiple islands. That's a feat much much more impressive than Boo's. And before Goku fought Frieza, Vegeta's blast was stated to be capable of destroying Namek, a huge planet. We also have a weakened King Piccolo removing a city off the map, and the blast was dwarfing mountains. Boo's feat is inconsistent, but the others aren't. Unless you're going to say that Boo = King Piccolo or something.

Let me explain it here.

King Piccolo's most powerful blast at that time, as he was weakened, dwarfed mountains, and completely wiped the city off the map. Then we have Piccolo's explosion which even after Goku absorbed some of it, and Piccolo was weakened himself, it still wiped everything off the island and razed it. An island comparable to the size of a small continent. It moves smoothly.

Goku was the strongest in the 23rd TB, and he was probably fresh at the time of releasing the Super Kamehameha. The Super Kamehameha was his strongest technique too, so about it being moon level isn't so out of reach.
Edited by supersaqer, Aug 25 2014, 01:26 AM.
Posted Image

Speed-o'-Sound Sonic
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mihawk
Member Avatar


supersaqer
 
Although he did state that Piccolo's explosion was the greatest ki he felt, but doesn't have to include himself. He completely withstood the explosion, but wouldn't be capable of withstanding the Super Kamehameha in that crippled state. Goku probably meant it's the greatest ki he ever felt from somebody, and not including himself.

A character's respective ki has been compared multiple times to opposing ki. There's no reason to believe it wasn't in this case apart from wanting one blast to seem stronger than the other.

supersaqer
 
Base Goku, during the Frieza Saga, kicked Frieza through multiple islands. That's a feat much much more impressive than Boo's. And before Goku fought Frieza, Vegeta's blast was stated to be capable of destroying Namek, a huge planet. We also have a weakened King Piccolo removing a city off the map, and the blast was dwarfing mountains. Boo's feat is inconsistent, but the others aren't. Unless you're going to say that Boo = King Piccolo or something.

Once again saying something is inconsistent isn't some weapon that you use in arguments. When claiming inconsistency you don't choose one feat over another unless you're biased. That, or you try find another all inclusive theory or explanation such failure of fan scaling among other ideas. Or as CC explained on Infinity it's possible and likely the the universe, moon and other planets are dissimilar to our own. If we go by the sketch in the Daiz (I don't not being a Daiz fan, among other issues) then the universe is under 10 million miles in diameter.
supersaqer
 
King Piccolo's most powerful blast at that time, as he was weakened, dwarfed mountains, and completely wiped the city off the map. Then we have Piccolo's explosion which even after Goku absorbed some of it, and Piccolo was weakened himself, it still wiped everything off the island and razed it. An island comparable to the size of a small continent. It moves smoothly.

Goku was the strongest in the 23rd TB, and he was probably fresh at the time of releasing the Super Kamehameha. The Super Kamehameha was his strongest technique too, so about it being moon level isn't so out of reach.

I'm not necessarily saying you're wrong about Goku's blast being "moon level", just that it's inconsistent with other feats such as Boo's, SPC's crater, among others. Choosing the one you prefer in this argument shows your lack of objectivity.

Posted Image

Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ supersaqer
Member Avatar
Transcendent

Quote:
 
A character's respective ki has been compared multiple times to opposing ki. There's no reason to believe it wasn't in this case apart from wanting one blast to seem stronger than the other.
He probably compared his "Ki" to the power Piccolo was generating, not to his technique.

Quote:
 
Once again saying something is inconsistent isn't some weapon that you use in arguments. When claiming inconsistency you don't choose one feat over another unless you're biased. That, or you try find another all inclusive theory or explanation such failure of fan scaling among other ideas. Or as CC explained on Infinity it's possible and likely the the universe, moon and other planets are dissimilar to our own. If we go by the sketch in the Daiz (I don't not being a Daiz fan, among other issues) then the universe is under 10 million miles in diameter.
Of all of the feats in the series, why would you choose Boo's feat? It's clearly inconsistent. I'm unsure about the universe argument CC made, and the sketch in the Daiz. It's vague.

Quote:
 
I'm not necessarily saying you're wrong about Goku's blast being "moon level", just that it's inconsistent with other feats such as Boo's, SPC's crater, among others. Choosing the one you prefer in this argument shows your lack of objectivity.
SPC's crater? Cell was fighting Gohan in a beam struggle, so the crater that was created doesn't mean that Cell's attack is weak. He stated that he can destroy the solar system with it. If he couldn't, then why would he say that? If he couldn't even blow up the Earth, why would he say the solar system?

Boo's feat is the only thing I see inconsistent, as well as Roshi's moon busting (as I take it as a gag scene).

Posted Image

Speed-o'-Sound Sonic
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mihawk
Member Avatar


supersaqer
 
He probably compared his "Ki" to the power Piccolo was generating, not to his technique.

Either way it was in the context of the blast. If he was comparing the ki Piccolo was generating then he'd be referring to the ki he generated for his own blast.

supersaqer
 
Of all of the feats in the series, why would you choose Boo's feat? It's clearly inconsistent. I'm unsure about the universe argument CC made, and the sketch in the Daiz. It's vague.

I'm not choosing Boo's feat, I'm merely saying that your argument is inconsistent because of it. I'm not saying that Goku isn't an X buster, just that the evidence is sufficient due to contradictions to make a palatable argument.

supersaqer
 
SPC's crater? Cell was fighting Gohan in a beam struggle, so the crater that was created doesn't mean that Cell's attack is weak. He stated that he can destroy the solar system with it. If he couldn't, then why would he say that? If he couldn't even blow up the Earth, why would he say the solar system?

Boo's feat is the only thing I see inconsistent, as well as Roshi's moon busting (as I take it as a gag scene).

I thought SPC's blast that took out half of Gohan's ki made a crater? Maybe I'm wrong. There's tons of other examples. I just picked went to a random scene and found a blast meant to kill Gohan by Freeza do absolutely jack.

Roshi's scene doesn't have to be a gag scene if you simply have him amping to Saiyan Saga levels through a glorified USSJ boost.

Posted Image

Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ supersaqer
Member Avatar
Transcendent

Quote:
 
Either way it was in the context of the blast. If he was comparing the ki Piccolo was generating then he'd be referring to the ki he generated for his own blast.
So you do think that crippled Goku can withstand Super Kamehameha with some effort?

Quote:
 
I'm not choosing Boo's feat, I'm merely saying that your argument is inconsistent because of it. I'm not saying that Goku isn't an X buster, just that the evidence is sufficient due to contradictions to make a palatable argument.
But that feat is inconsistent, and you can take it as a grain of salt.

Quote:
 
I thought SPC's blast that took out half of Gohan's ki made a crater? Maybe I'm wrong. There's tons of other examples. I just picked went to a random scene and found a blast meant to kill Gohan by Freeza do absolutely jack.

Roshi's scene doesn't have to be a gag scene if you simply have him amping to Saiyan Saga levels through a glorified USSJ boost.
What took out half of Gohan's ki was his blast, but Gohan took on the blast to save Vegeta, so that doesn't count.

If that was the case, then Roshi would have destroyed Old Piccolo, but it's not.
Posted Image

Speed-o'-Sound Sonic
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mihawk
Member Avatar


supersaqer
 
So you do think that crippled Goku can withstand Super Kamehameha with some effort?

I don't know nor do I see the relevancy. :p
supersaqer
 
But that feat is inconsistent, and you can take it as a grain of salt.

Once again just saying things like vague and inconsistent aren't arguments by themselves. They just show that you shouldn't make the argument for or against, unless you can encompass all off the feats under a single umbrella.
supersaqer
 
What took out half of Gohan's ki was his blast, but Gohan took on the blast to save Vegeta, so that doesn't count.

If that was the case, then Roshi would have destroyed Old Piccolo, but it's not.

OK that does sound about right. Gohan should've taken the brunt of the attack.

There's still tons of other situations way past Vegeta's claimed planet busting in the Namek and Cell saga where blasts don't amount to anything such as Freeza against Gohan along with a handful after the scene.

Posted Image

Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ supersaqer
Member Avatar
Transcendent

Quote:
 
I don't know nor do I see the relevancy. :p
Here comes the problem. I don't think Goku can withstand it in the crippled state he was when he took on Piccolo's explosion.

Quote:
 
Once again just saying things like vague and inconsistent aren't arguments by themselves. They just show that you shouldn't make the argument for or against, unless you can encompass all off the feats under a single umbrella.
You could place them under two umbrellas, as you say :p . One is that they're inconsistent, and the other that they just have the range of that level.

Quote:
 
OK that does sound about right. Gohan should've taken the brunt of the attack.

There's still tons of other situations way past Vegeta's claimed planet busting in the Namek and Cell saga where blasts don't amount to anything such as Freeza against Gohan along with a handful after the scene.
But they are meant to destroy the character, not the environment they're in. Or you could basically say the feats are inconsistent. Two choices.

Anyways, Ten can do much more than Piccolo's normal blast with a casual one. He can fire multiple of those while bloodlusted, and take out the entire battlefield.
Posted Image

Speed-o'-Sound Sonic
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ Pelador
Member Avatar
Crazy Awesome Legend

Not sure that he can. Just because Piccolo could do such things, doesn't mean Tien was capable of the same, even if he was stronger. Power doesn't equal technique. Hence how Goten couldn't fly but he could have probably killed Freeza in one punch. Tien or even Goku never showed off any kind of casual blasts like that. I'm not saying that they definitely couldn't. It's just that since it's never shown then all you can do is assume. Assumptions aren't facts. They are guesses. So that would just be poor debating.


Posted Image

http://www.youtube.com/user/jonjits
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ Pyrus
Member Avatar


Gosh, there's so much of THIS going on that it's frying my monitor.

I should expect that from this kind of versus, though. Check it out.
Spoiler: click to toggle
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Daniel
Member Avatar
I like Pokémon

The United States Armed Forces, has a combined strength of 1,367,000 personnel including reserve personnel. No where near the amount of 2 million soldiers being through around, just clearing that up. As for having one a couple hundred planes, that is entirely incorrect. We have over 2,700 fixed wing figter air craft in our Air Force alone. These are planes that require pilots not including drones, support aircraft, Apaches, etc. The Army, Navy and the Marine Corps have an additional combined total of 800 fixed wing fighters. Brining our total of jet fighters to near 4000. That is quite a bit more than 100. The lowest grade fighter craft we have is the F/18, these fly at speeds of 1900km/h. Our F-22 fighters fly at speeds well over 2500km/h, we have 350 F-22s in stock. In addition to that we have prototype F-35s which our being developed to have a speed of 3000 albeit only a couple of them are actually operational. We have 12 Aircraft Carriers which means our planes can be fueled and mobilized anywhere with no need for a base. Let's say he magically using his god powerful "casual blasts" kills 750,000 Army personnel, The Navy (which have submarines armed with tomahawk missiles with are damn close to a nuke), and 300,000 marines. I highly doubt he could survive well over 4000 jets along with 1000 attack choppers and AC-130s coming at him with speeds well over 2000km\h all at once firing god knows what, every missile and bullet the US could get their hands on, and every f***ed up disease known to man being dropped on him.

Well unless of course he fires one of those casual blasts and just kills everyone.
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ Pyrus
Member Avatar


Potato Underling
Aug 25 2014, 12:12 PM
The United States Armed Forces, has a combined strength of 1,367,000 personnel including reserve personnel. No where near the amount of 2 million soldiers being through around, just clearing that up. As for having one a couple hundred planes, that is entirely incorrect. We have over 2,700 fixed wing figter air craft in our Air Force alone. These are planes that require pilots not including drones, support aircraft, Apaches, etc. The Army, Navy and the Marine Corps have an additional combined total of 800 fixed wing fighters. Brining our total of jet fighters to near 4000. That is quite a bit more than 100. The lowest grade fighter craft we have is the F/18, these fly at speeds of 1900km/h. Our F-22 fighters fly at speeds well over 2500km/h, we have 350 F-22s in stock. In addition to that we have prototype F-35s which our being developed to have a speed of 3000 albeit only a couple of them are actually operational. We have 12 Aircraft Carriers which means our planes can be fueled and mobilized anywhere with no need for a base. Let's say he magically using his god powerful "casual blasts" kills 750,000 Army personnel, The Navy (which have submarines armed with tomahawk missiles with are damn close to a nuke), and 300,000 marines. I highly doubt he could survive well over 4000 jets along with 1000 attack choppers and AC-130s coming at him with speeds well over 2000km\h all at once firing god knows what, every missile and bullet the US could get their hands on, and every f***ed up disease known to man being dropped on him.

Well unless of course he fires one of those casual blasts and just kills everyone.
From what I've gathered of this thread so far—and correct me if I'm wrong—Tenshinhan would naturally (see: easily) tank or dodge everything, and he'd just jump so high the Tomahawks wouldn't affect him. The entire US Armed Forces would be reduced to 100,000 men in ten seconds from casual country buster blasts, and those remaining 100,000 personnel would be killed so quickly it was like they didn't even exist.

But good post nonetheless.
Spoiler: click to toggle
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mihawk
Member Avatar


supersaqer
 
You could place them under two umbrellas, as you say :p . One is that they're inconsistent, and the other that they just have the range of that level

Inconsistent isn't an umbrella. It has holes in it. Them having "range of that level" is contradicted many times. I don't think you understand what I meant by the umbrella metaphor haha.

supersaqer
 
But they are meant to destroy the character, not the environment they're in.

By the leave of you and all the "DBZ protectors" here Goku and Gohan have "planet level durability". So if Freeza launches a blast meant to kill Gohan, the fact that it doesn't even destroy a mountain or island contradicts the entire ideology of Raditz being "moon level", and people casually leveling cities with ki blasts. I'm not saying that there isn't evidence for those, as there is in a sense, just that it's inconsistent.

supersaqer
 
Or you could basically say the feats are inconsistent. Two choices.

As I've said before when you say "inconsistent" you're saying we're both wrong. None are right in that case. You've seen it used multiple times as a weapon by people who barely grasp concepts of logical deduction.

Posted Image

Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
+ supersaqer
Member Avatar
Transcendent

If I said anything more, it would be more specifying about how consistent the feats were. While even weakened, King Piccolo displayed the feat of wiping a large city off the map, and have the blast dwarf mountains. Crippled Piccolo was shown to wipe and raze an island close to the size of a small continent. Fresh Goku with his strongest technique is capable of leveling the moon. All of that is consistent. Then we have Vegeta's planet busting statement. See? We're moving fluidly here. If we continued with the inconsistency here, we will be running in circles, so I would leave this here.

If King Piccolo showed the ability to wipe out a city normally, then why wouldn't a stronger character be capable of doing the feat and more?
Posted Image

Speed-o'-Sound Sonic
Member Offline View Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Join the millions that use us for their forum communities. Create your own forum today.
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Other Versus · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Theme Designed by McKee91